Every off-season the Rockies sign a handful of pitchers to minor league contracts to fill out the Triple-A roster and give the Rockies roster more pitching depth. This off-season, the Rockies inked their first MiLB deal with former big-leaguer Geoff Hartlieb.
Since 2019, Hartlieb has pitched in MLB games for the Pirates, Mets, and most recently in 2023 for the Marlins. Things have never panned out for the now 29-year-old pitcher at the major league level, but there are aspects to his game that jump off the page. In 2023, Hartlieb only appeared in 2 MLB games, and in those 2 games, his fastball was averaging 96.0 MPH. Velocity plays at any level of baseball.
Geoff Hartlieb has gotten ideal results at each level of Minor League Baseball. He strikes out a lot of batters, limits walks, induces a lot of ground-balls, and gives up plenty of weak contact. To see how all of that will fare in the Pacific Coast League will indicate whether Hartlieb could be a potential relief pitcher for the Rockies.
Since 2021, Geoff Hartlieb has only thrown 3 pitches. His best pitch in 2023 was his sinker, averaging 94.1 MPH in 2023. In an extremely small sample size, he threw it 24 times while nobody had an exit velocity over 95 MPH against it. Hartlieb also has a fastball that averaged 96 MPH, and if located properly, it’s a good MLB pitch. Then for his breaking ball Hartlieb uses a slider, (it has a lot of vertical movement so it’s not a sweeper). It had a 33.3 Whiff%; that’ll play for a strikeout pitch.
What Went Wrong
His success in the minor leagues centered mainly around his command. When he threw in the zone, guys were swinging and missing and the contact they did make was mostly on the ground. However, each MLB stint for Hartlieb has been plagued by inconsistent command. Since 2020, Hartlieb has walked 33 players compared to striking out 31 in his major league appearances (8.4 BB/9 – 7.9 SO/9). You can’t be a competent big leaguer walking that many guys, even with above average stuff.
Pitching is very stressful and pitching in MLB gets even worse which has likely contributed to Hartlieb’s struggles. Since 2022, Hartlieb’s BB/9 has been no higher than 3.69 in MiLB games. He’s proven that he can limit walks and I believe if he does it once more in 2024 an opportunity will be given to him by the Rockies.
Why You Should Be Excited
In recent memory the Rockies have had a lot of “diamond in the rough” relievers work out for them. Think Greg Holland, Jairo Diaz, Daniel Bard, and Tyler Kinley, just to list a few. Hartlieb is a reach right now, but you can tell the Rockies were intrigued as they signed him at the outset of MLB free agency. Just from his arsenal and his history, I believe we will see him pitch at some point for the Rockies. With injuries inevitable to pitchers, you can never have too many relievers. If he performs in Spring Training and early in the minors, Hartlieb can be a critical next man up.


Leave a Reply